Quick answerA useful portfolio review is more than deciding whether you like the colours.
Signal 01
Ask what the portfolio shows
Choose two or three examples and visit the live sites if available. On a phone, try the menu, read a service page, and find the contact path. Notice whether the design stays clear at different screen sizes. If you can, test the form—but do not submit an unnecessary message to a real business.
Ask the designer what they personally handled: strategy, content structure, visual design, build, or only a portion of the project. Find out what the original client needed and how the solution addressed it. A screenshot cannot prove sales results, search rankings, or ease of maintenance, so request context rather than assuming outcomes.
Consider whether the examples demonstrate range. A site for a different industry can still show useful skills, but ask how those skills would adapt to your customers. Do not expect an exact copy; your website should reflect your own services and business information.
Signal 02
Connect the work to your project
Use portfolio examples to start a conversation about process, not to make a decision alone. Compare the designer's explanation with the written scope, communication style, ownership terms, and support.
For Hamilton businesses, LOITTEB's web design page (https://loitteb.ca/web-design-hamilton/) describes its approach to custom websites. If you already have a site you want assessed, request a free website review (https://loitteb.ca/free-website-review/).